403 Forbidden

Nine Moons » Blog Archive : The Atonement and The Book of Mormon Musical » The Atonement and The Book of Mormon Musical

The Atonement and The Book of Mormon Musical

MCQ - April 24, 2011

I’m always astonished to hear that there is little or no coordination among the speakers at General Conference.  We correlate and pre-approve everything in this Church, but apparently, to a great extent, conference has escaped this tendency.  Yet somehow, despite this, there is always a broad span of subjects covered and rarely a lot of overlap.  This time, however, there were two talks on the Atonement.  An overzealous attempt at correlation might have squelched one of these, but that would have been a mistake, as they covered the topic in different ways and they bracketed the conference nicely, one occurring in the Saturday morning session and one in the Sunday afternoon session.  Both were by members of the seventy, the first by Elder Kent F. Richards, and the last by Elder C. Scott Grow (no relation to his more famous counterpart, Elder C. Spot Run) (ok, I apologize for that joke).

Both of these excellent talks focused primarily on the universality of the Atonement.   Thankfully, they didn’t repeat the shopworn etymology of the word at-one-ment, or focus on the hows or whys of the atonement, about which we have had some genuinely fascinating discussions here in the bloggernacle.  Instead, both talks focused on the effects of the atonement and how these effects can become available to us.

Elder Richards was a surgeon, and after observing that pain is something that all experience at times, and that pain can not only be endured, but can even be advantageous, he said:

The Savior is not a silent observer. He Himself knows personally and infinitely the pain we face.

“He suffereth the pains of all men, yea, the pains of every living creature, both men, women, and children.”

“Let us therefore come boldly unto the throne of grace, that we may obtain mercy, and find grace to help in time of need.”

Sometimes in the depth of pain, we are tempted to ask, “Is there no balm in Gilead; is there no physician there?”  I testify the answer is yes, there is a physician. The Atonement of Jesus Christ covers all these conditions and purposes of mortality.

The purpose of the Atonement then, is not just remission of sins, but also to provide healing and relief for all pains and conditions of mortality.

Similarly, Elder Grow emphasized the universal nature of the atonement, that it was made for the remission of sins and also for the comfort of those who were in pain because of the sins or misdeeds of others:

Not only did He pay the price for the sins of all men, but He also took “upon him the pains and the sicknesses of his people.” And He took “upon him their infirmities, that his bowels may be filled with mercy, … that he may know according to the flesh how to succor his people according to their infirmities.”

The Savior felt the weight of the anguish of all mankind―the anguish of sin and of sorrow. “Surely he has borne our griefs, and carried our sorrows.”

Through His Atonement, He heals not only the transgressor, but He also heals the innocent who suffer because of those transgressions. As the innocent exercise faith in the Savior and in His Atonement and forgive the transgressor, they too can be healed.

These are powerful testimonies of the healing power of the Atonement, made by Christ in the meridian of time for the benefit of all mankind, following which, and as a condition of which, he died and rose again.  It is this that we celebrate this Easter season.  And I add my testimony to those borne during conference, of the reality and power of this great selfless act, the atonement of Jesus Christ.  Though I don’t understand how it works, it has blessed my life in ways that I am well aware of and in ways I fear I am still quite ignorant of, and I am grateful for it every day.  I believe the Atonement has the power to truly change us as people, and it is through its power that we experience the change of heart that is required of all who wish to truly become followers of Jesus Christ.

In thinking about this great Atonement this season, I was reminded of the discussions that have taken place regarding the Book of Mormon musical currently playing on Broadway.  There have been a number of interesting discussions about it already, two of which you can read about here and here.  For myself, I have no opinion on  the musical itself because I haven’t seen it, but if those who have seen it are accurate in portraying its general message then it appears to be saying something similar to what Parker and Stone (two of its creators) have said about Mormonism before, which is perhaps best summed up by this South Park episode:


In other words, they are saying that Mormonism is based on obvious lies, but it’s useful in that it teaches people to be nice and help one another. Most of those who have seen the musical apparently come away with a similar idea: Mormons are loving, warm, wonderful people, who must be a bit stupid because Mormonism is a bit idiotic. Despite this, it can be very helpful in giving people purpose and in teaching good behavior.

This message is not terrible, as far as it goes, and the fun that is made of Mormonism in the musical and elsewhere by Parker and Stone is mostly harmless, perhaps even comlimentary in some ways, but it misses the point entirely because it fails to acount for things like the Atonement, as discussed above.

This is a similar point to the one made by Andrew Sullivan, which was linked in the BCC post by John C.  Religion in general, and Mormonism in particular, is not really of any use if it’s all based on a pack of lies.  There’s no way to really change people’s behavior, in any meaningful or permanent way, without changing their hearts, and no nice story, however firmly believed in by any number of gullible idiots, ever had any power to do that.  The power of the Atonement is the only thing that ever can change hearts, change people and redeem mankind, and unless the Atonement really happened, Mormonism specifically, and Christianity in general, is useless and powerless.

So Parker and Stone can go on thinking of Mormonism as a useful lie, and Mormons as wonderful, nice helpful idiots, but the reality is that the thing they ignorantly recognize as “warmth” and “niceness” in the Mormons they have met is actually the transformative power of the Atonement of Jesus Christ, working in the lives of those who choose to believe in Christ and attempt to follow him.


  1. Not to be contrary, because this was a great post, but is there “transformative power” in non-Christian religions? In other words, can Islam transform a person’s heart?

    I speak as someone who has studied Islam somewhat in-depth, and heard very moving testimonies of people who have made the Hajj, and it’s hard not to consider them transformative experiences. Do you think the Atonement is somehow at work in these instances?

    Comment by Syphax — April 25, 2011 @ 7:01 pm

  2. The Atonement is universal, so yes, I’m sure it is, but I’m not in a position to discuss Islam because I just don’t know that much about it.

    If I had to guess, however, I would say that there is transformative power whenever the Spirit of God is involved, and the Spirit is involved whenever there is any degree of goodness or truth.

    Comment by MCQ — April 25, 2011 @ 9:01 pm

  3. Great post.

    Comment by Jack — April 26, 2011 @ 3:33 pm

  4. Well said. Thanks for this.

    Comment by Sarah — April 27, 2011 @ 10:19 am

  5. [...] About a week ago, you may have read an article in the New York Times by David Brooks regarding the message espoused by Matt Stone and Trey Parker’s Book of Mormon Musical. And if you read that, you may have read Andrew Sullivan’s article pushing back against Brooks or Joanna Brooks’s rather different disagreement. Maybe you got wind of the entire thing at BCC from John C’s article that posited that both Brooks and Sullivan fail because they argue along a false dichotomy. Maybe you saw MCQ’s article at 9 Moons that referenced nearly all of the above. [...]

    Pingback by The Awesome, Radical Transformational Potential of Religion | Wheat and Tares — April 30, 2011 @ 3:57 am

  6. Wonderful post. I too believe in the transformative power of the atonement, and love the Book of Mormon with all my heart. Thanks for this.

    Comment by sean — April 26, 2012 @ 2:14 pm

Leave a comment

RSS feed for comments on this post.
TrackBack URI